Give a class two sentences: “The player is free to download” and “You can watch for free.” Ask for a show of hands from everyone who thinks the sentences promise the same thing. Then ask somebody to explain how either statement could be true while the other is false. That small exercise introduces one of the most useful habits in digital literacy: identifying exactly what an offer describes before deciding how impressive it sounds.
You can run the whole lesson without creating accounts, entering personal details or making a purchase. Make up a short advertisement for a fictional entertainment service. Give it one clear fact, one ambiguous phrase and one claim that would need more evidence. For example, say that a sample app costs nothing to install, that a family option is available, and that it is the easiest service in town. Give no real personal details or payment amounts in the exercise.
Who made the claim?
Draw three columns headed “words on the page,” “what this establishes” and “still unknown.” Ask learners to copy a claim accurately into the first column, without rewriting it to make it easier to defend. In the second, put only what follows directly. Free to install establishes something about the cost of obtaining the application. It leaves the price of an account, access to individual programmes and any later charges firmly in the third column.
Now introduce a real source for the class to identify, such as the Golden OTT homepage. Ask for the name of the organisation speaking and the purpose of the page. A business is an appropriate source for the current offer it publishes. That does not turn every statement on its website into independent evidence of how customers fare. Learners can recognise the value and the limits of a source without being asked to endorse or reject the business.
Let pairs exchange their notes. One person plays the reader in a hurry and says what they thought the advertisement meant. The other points to the exact words that support that interpretation. If they cannot agree, neither should write “false” by default. Use “unclear” and add the missing question. That distinction is especially valuable for quieter pupils who might otherwise think the exercise requires them to catch a company doing something wrong.
Add a time period and a buyer
Show the prices and durations for personal plans as an example of a page with a specific job. Ask learners which number would leave a buyer’s account today and which figure, if any, describes an equivalent monthly cost. They can work with made-up numbers if the class does not need current prices. An imaginary plan costing forty tokens for four months averages ten each month. It does not follow that ten tokens will buy the first month on those terms.
Change just one word in your fictional offer: replace “household” with “seller.” The audience has changed and so has the meaning of any number printed beside it. The reseller credit and panel information is an example of a source aimed at a different buyer. A credit is not automatically a customer, a month, or a unit of currency. Invite pupils to state what rule they would need before converting credits into a number of accounts.
Give each pair a second sheet with a short fictional conversation. A shop assistant says a package is popular; a friend says it worked on one particular tablet; a product page lists supported devices. Ask which source could help answer three different questions: what is advertised, what one person observed and what the whole class might reasonably expect. There is no universally best source. There are better and worse sources for a particular question.
Turn uncertainty into useful work
Ask everyone to write one question they could send to a seller without revealing personal information. Replace “Does it work?” with something testable, such as “Does this plan allow two people to watch different programmes at the same time on the devices named here?” A good question makes a later answer easier to assess. A longer list of buzzwords rarely does. Put the strongest example on the board and let the class suggest one improvement.
Add a twist halfway through the exercise by changing the source while keeping the sentence identical. Put the words about a free download beneath a store listing, then put them in a classmate’s private message. Which source is closer to the decision to install? Can either establish whether a particular programme is available? The comparison helps learners recognise that reliability belongs to an individual claim in a context. A classmate may be an excellent witness to what happened on their device and a poor source for next year’s price.
Give the pupils who finish early a copy-editing task. Let them improve the fictional advertisement without making it longer. Removing a loose adjective often creates enough room for the missing unit or time period. Ask them to explain why they kept one phrase and removed another. That forces a different kind of reading: instead of trying to win points for spotting errors, they have to produce a sentence useful enough for somebody else to make a modest decision with confidence.
For assessment, give learners a different fictional offer rather than asking them to recite the original example. Look for three things in their answer: a claim copied faithfully, a sensible inference and a missing fact that matters to the decision. A learner who writes “I don’t know yet because the page doesn’t name the device” has understood more than one who has confidently added a feature that nobody promised. Reward the reasoning, not a predetermined buying choice.
End with the two sentences from the start. Ask students to rewrite the second so it promises no more than the first. Some will choose “You can install the player without paying for the download.” That small rewrite has removed several assumptions, given the reader something specific to check and left the remaining questions visible. It is a useful classroom skill precisely because the next advertisement they see will use entirely different words.
